Next VML Classic Book Group Meeting is Tuesday, June 17, 2014 from 4:30 - 6 p.m. in the Ventress Library Historical Room. Book selection is "A Bell for Adano" by John Hersey, which won the Pulitzer Prize for Novel in 1945. New members welcome. Please contact Chris Woods at the library's Reference Desk if you need help obtaining a copy of the book or have any questions about the group. Light refreshments served! Library phone is 781-834-5535 or e-mail cwoods@ocln.org
_______________________________
STUDY GUIDE TO BOOK
A Bell
for Adano
Author
John Hersey (1914-1993)
Type of Work
Novel
Type of Plot
Social realism
Time of Plot
1943
Locale
Adano, Italy
First Published
1944
Principal characters:
MAJOR VICTOR JOPPOLO,
the American military governor of Adano
SERGEANT
BORTH, Major Joppolo’s subordinate
CAPTAIN PURVIS,
the head of the military police
GENERAL MARVIN,
the commander-in-chief of the American invasion troops and Major Joppolo’s
superior
The Story:
When the American army
invaded Sicily,
Major Victor Joppolo was placed in command of Adano. He set up his office in
the city hall, rehired the janitor, and investigated the records left by the
Fascist mayor, who had fled to the hills. Soon after his arrival, Major Joppolo
summoned the leading citizens of the town and asked them, through Giuseppe, his
interpreter, what they considered the most important thing to be done. Some
answered that the shortage of food was the most pressing problem. Others
insisted that what the town needed most was its bell, which had been removed by
the Fascists. The bell, it seemed, had a soothing tone and it regulated the
lives of Adano’s residents. The major promised every effort to recover the
bell. Meanwhile, the problem was to obtain food and to have produce brought
into the town. In order that his directives would be understood and carried
out, the major issued proclamations that the town crier, after being silent for
so long, hastened to shout in the village.
On Sunday morning, when the
major attended mass at one of the churches, he noticed a blonde girl sitting in
front of him. When he later asked Giuseppe about her, the interpreter assumed
that the American’s interest had nothing to do with official business. Major
Joppolo’s primary interest, however, was the girl’s father, Tomasino, owner of
a fishing fleet. He had Giuseppe ask Tomasino to come to see him, but Tomasino,
distrustful of authority, refused to come to the headquarters. The major
therefore went to Tomasino, followed by practically all the townspeople. The
old Italian was defiant, sure that the major had come to arrest him. Major
Joppolo finally convinced him that he meant neither to arrest him nor to ask
for a cut in the proceeds from the sale of the fish but rather wanted him to go
out with his fishing fleet, despite the danger of mines.
The major and his policies
had become the subject of much discussion among the people. The Fascist mayor
provided a great deal of amusement because he had come out of hiding and been
paroled into Sergeant Borth’s custody. Every morning, the mayor had to go to
Sergeant Borth and publicly confess a Fascist sin. Giuseppe was astonished to
discover that the major meant what he said when he told him to report for work
at seven in the morning. Gargano, the former Fascist policeman, learned that he
could no longer force the others to make way for him when they stood in line at
the bakery.
While driving through Adano
one day, General Marvin found the road blocked by a mule cart. The driver,
having had his daily quota of wine, was sleeping peacefully. When the mule
refused to budge, the general ordered the vehicle thrown into the ditch.
Reluctantly, the soldiers dumped the cart, mule, and sleeping driver. Swearing
furiously, the general drove to the city hall, where he confronted Major
Joppolo and ordered that all carts be forbidden to enter Adano.
The next day, a group of
townspeople besieged the major to explain that the carts were essential, for
they brought food and water into the town. Major Joppolo countermanded the
general’s order and telephoned Captain Purvis that he would accept full
responsibility. Captain Purvis, anxious to keep out of trouble, ordered
Lieutenant Trapani to make a memorandum and send it to General Marvin. The
lieutenant, out of regard for Major Joppolo, put the memorandum among Purvis’
papers in the hope that the captain, who rarely looked through his files, would
never find it.
Major Joppolo’s efforts to
restore the bell were not successful, for it had been melted down by the
Fascists. A young naval officer in charge of a nearby station promised to
obtain a ship’s bell for him.
In the meantime, Captain
Purvis had gone through the papers on his desk and had found the memorandum for
General Marvin. He ordered it forwarded at once. Lieutenant Trapani mailed it,
but addressed it to the wrong person at headquarters in Algiers. From there, it was forwarded to the
general’s aide, Colonel Middleton. Every day the colonel met with General
Marvin and went over important communications. Accordingly, he was halfway
through Purvis’ letter before he realized what it was. He tried to go on to the
next letter, but it was too late. The general had heard Major Joppolo’s name
and that of Adano, and he remembered both.
The bell arrived in Adano.
It was touched, prodded, sounded by the experts, and admired by everybody. When
it pealed forth, the townspeople declared that its tone was even better than
that of the old bell. The major was a hero. To show their appreciation and
affection, the townspeople had him taken to a photographer. A local artist painted
his portrait from the photograph. At the celebration that night, Sergeant Borth
became very, very drunk. He refused to take orders from Major Joppolo, saying
that the major was no longer in any position to give orders. Captain Purvis,
said the sergeant, almost sobbing, had received a letter from General Marvin,
ordering Major Joppolo back to Algiers.
The next morning, the major said goodbye to Borth, who apologized for his
conduct of the previous night. The major asked him to help his successor make
the people happy. As he drove away from the town, he heard in the distance the
tolling of a bell, the new bell for Adano.
Critical Evaluation:
John Hersey’s A Bell for
Adano, which was published in 1944 and for which the novelist was awarded
the Pulitzer Prize the following year, achieved enormous popularity in its day
and was seen as a classic war novel. Because Hersey had experienced the war as
a correspondent, the novel was thought to be considerably more realistic than
it actually is. With some qualifications, the work can, however, be placed in
that genre of American fiction called realism.
The situation of an
Italian-speaking American officer, Major Joppolo, serving as administrator of
the small Sicilian village of Adano allows Hersey to set out his beliefs about
the primacy of democracy over Fascism, the duty of leaders to serve the people,
the need for administrative control, and the disasters that result when people
are left to their own devices. These beliefs coincided with the opinions held
by many Americans at the close of World War II. It was consequently the perfect
reading material for Americans who needed to believe that war was necessary and
that the United States was
helping the rest of the world by occupying Italy. It was also pleasant to
believe that amid the difficulties of war there could be moments of humor and
that one could encounter good simple folk. The novel is optimistic, often comic
in tone, and ultimately romantic in its conclusion: When Major Joppolo is
ordered by General Marvin to leave the town, he stops for one final time to
hear the ringing of the bell that his efforts had brought the people. “It was a
fine sound on the summer air,” the novel maintains, and the reader is left with
the image of Joppolo as a decent man who has done his best. That the town has
little future is immaterial; the residents of Adano will simply continue their
bungling ways. The main conflict in the novel stems from the clashes between
Major Joppolo, who believes in democracy and servant leadership, and General
Marvin, whose selfishness and cruelty in shooting the mule and ordering carts
out of the village make him the symbol of American arrogance and lack of
consideration for the native population. There is additional conflict and
satire in Joppolo’s struggles with postwar bureaucracy; his reaction to his
“Instructions to Civil Affairs Officers,” which is to tear up the pages and use
his own judgment, affords both humor and commentary on the unrealistic,
theoretical approach to occupying a small town.
That General Marvin, who
has the right to order Joppolo to leave Adano, is ultimately the victor,
suggests that Hersey believes that it is important for individuals to do
something good, even if it is only a small gesture. No one in the novel changes
or develops; the soldiers continue to be superficial, the townspeople petty,
the Army bureaucracy uncaring. Life goes on, but it is vital that individuals
do good deeds and therein find satisfaction.
Most of the Italian
villagers are depicted as foolish, nostalgic, and opportunistic. Hersey
achieves some of his best humor at their expense, frequently using caricature
and such tags as “lazy Fatta” and “formidable Margherita.” Hersey also gives
some of the townspeople dignity, however. Old Cacopardo’s reproach of General
Marvin’s lack of appreciation of the antique mahogany table on which the
general and his aide are playing mumblety-peg shows the clash of cultures and
allows Hersey to point out the inability of most Americans to realize the
richness of other histories and cultures. This same theme is echoed in the
earliest conversations about the village bell when “small Zito” maintains that
the bell will be of greater significance than additional food would be. Zito
rejects a replica of the American Liberty Bell: “I do not think the people of
Adano want any liberty that has a crack in it.”
In his depictions of the
soldiers Chuck and Polak, who seek only drink and sexual escapades and who
destroy the art objects in the house where they are billeted, Hersey provides a
biting commentary on the behavior of American soldiers abroad. Some reviewers
in fact questioned Hersey’s accuracy, particularly regarding the language he
ascribed to the soldiers, which was considered shocking at the time.
The novel is more a series
of vignettes than a complex narrative; there is little if any interior action.
Hersey is at his best in depicting isolated incidents: Major Joppolo’s arrival
in Adano, the first visit with Tomasino and his family, the Hemingway-inspired
dialogue between Chuck and Polak, the conversations about the crack in the
American Liberty Bell, the final moments when Major Joppolo stops to hear the
bell.
A Bell for Adano has an important history and keeps a secure place in
American popular fiction and war literature. The novel eventually became both a
Broadway play and a motion picture. Hersey’s subsequent publication of Hiroshima (1946)
further solidified the critical reputation of A Bell for Adano and gave
it additional credibility.
Bibliography:
Bradbury, Malcolm. The
Modern American Novel. New York: Oxford University
Press, 1984. A helpful summary of twentieth century American fiction, which
places A Bell for Adano in the mainstream of conventional realism and
naturalism.
Gemme, Francis. John
Hersey’s “A Bell for Adano,” “Hiroshima,” and Other Works: A Critical
Commentary. New York:
Monarch Press, 1966. A brief survey for beginning students. Good cursory
treatment of Hersey’s works and an overview of the initial reception of his
novels.
Huse, Nancy Lyman. John
Hersey and James Agee: A Reference Guide. Boston: G. K. Hall, 1978. Extremely helpful
compilation of materials for research. Includes reviews from the time of
initial publication.
Sanders, David. John
Hersey. New Haven, Conn.: College and University Press, 1967.
Excellent overview of Hersey and his work; traces significant themes and
beliefs. Good treatment of Hersey’s life, with critical attention to his
literary output.
Sanders, David. John
Hersey Revisited. Boston:
Twayne, 1990. A competent survey of Her-sey’s life and works, updating the
previous information on the critical estimate of Hersey and of A Bell for
Adano. Also includes bibliography.
“Critical
Evaluation” by Katherine Hanley
A Bell for Adano
Author
John Hersey (1914-1993)
Classification
Social realism
First Published
1944
Locale
Adano, Italy
Themes
War, politics and law, social issues, and education
Time of Plot
1943
Recommended Ages
15-18
American Army Major Victor Joppolo is in charge of the
contingent of troops occupying the Italian village of Adano
shortly after the Allied victory there in World War II. This is the story of
his success in helping the inhabitants replace Fascism with democracy.
Principal characters:
MAJOR VICTOR JOPPOLO,
an American of Italian ancestry, the commanding officer of the American troops
occupying Adano, Sicily, during World War II
SERGEANT
LEONARD BORTH, Joppolo’s immediate subordinate, a much-traveled American
citizen of Hungarian heritage
GENERAL MARVIN,
the bad-tempered commander in chief of the American invasion forces, Joppolo’s
superior officer
The Story
Major Victor Joppolo,
accompanied by his next in command, Sergeant Leonard Borth, enters Adano just
behind the American invading forces who have come to occupy the small Italian
village. When Joppolo reaches the pier at Adano, he touches the ground with the
palm of his hand in a symbolic gesture of homecoming. Joppolo’s loving
acceptance of the language, habits, and culture of the people of Adano form the
base for his successful efforts to start them on the road to democracy and
freedom. This road, however, is no freeway. Obstacles appear at every turn,
caused by the collision of a variety of human ambitions, transports, and
jealousies.
John Hersey structures the
novel as a series of episodes, each dealing with a problem for which Joppolo
must devise an acceptable solution. Parallel to these episodes is the story of
Joppolo’s hesitant courtship of Tina, a village woman. When finally Sergeant
Borth, a much more aggressive lover, finds a means to devise a private meeting
between Joppolo and Tina, their assignation is interrupted before Joppolo has
had time to be unfaithful to the wife he left behind.
Another story line revolves
around the search for a new bell for Adano. The previous bell has been removed
by the Fascists, who sent it away to be melted and used for ammunition. After
periodic references to and actions taken on behalf of the missing bell, Joppolo
succeeds in finding a replacement and in having it installed before his own
departure. Joppolo’s leave-taking takes place to the sound of the ringing of
the new bell.
Throughout the story,
General Marvin, a man of short temper and little compassion, acts as a foil to
Joppolo. One day when Marvin is passing through Adano on his way somewhere
else, he and a few of his soldiers are blocked by a mule cart whose driver has
fallen asleep. Unable to get the mule to move, Marvin’s soldiers dump the whole
vehicle, including the driver and the mule, into a ditch. Marvin then issues
the edict that henceforth all carts are forbidden in Adano. Since without the
carting of food and water the villagers would perish, Major Joppolo
countermands the commander’s orders. There follows a series of actions
instigated by various enlisted men who attempt to misplace or otherwise lose
Joppolo’s countermanding order. This subterfuge succeeds for the time it takes
for Joppolo to find a replacement bell for Adano and to set into motion the
fundamentals of democratic government. Joppolo leaves Adano richer for his
interaction with representatives of his own forebears, just as the people of
Adano are richer for their interaction with Joppolo, who stands for one of
their own sons returned home.
Providing novelistic length
and a sense of the passage of time, various other episodes provide a comic
perspective that counterbalances the occasional references to the tragic losses
characteristic of war. For example, after Joppolo sets up his command post in
the city hall he receives a series of visits by citizens of Adano, many of whom
appear more like stereotypical comic characters from the commedia dell’ arte
than like credible human beings. The people of Adano, with few exceptions,
never discuss an issue calmly; they loudly assert positions. Their emotions are
comically intense. Indeed, most of the Italian citizens of Adano are presented
as simple but lovable people, like small children clustering around the knees
of a good father come to rescue them from the giant monster of twenty years of
Fascist rule.
Themes and Meanings
Victor Joppolo is a model
American soldier who respects the traditional values of home and hearth, even
extending across the seas to the lands of his European ancestors. Hersey
comments on this aspect of the American invasion forces in a foreword to the
novel, saying that it is a lucky thing for the United States to have “a fund of
men who speak the languages of the lands we must invade, who understand the
ways and have listened to their parents sing the folk songs and have tasted the
wine of the land on the palate of their memories.” For Hersey, the American
forces carrying messages of love and freedom from tyranny, along with a
pragmatic “knowhow,” are the wave of the future, the world’s hope for peace and
prosperity.
The conflict that develops
between representatives of the “good” man Joppolo and the “bad” man Marvin is
not simply a skirmish over leadership styles. Rather, it is an arena for the
contending forces of democracy and Fascism, demonstrating clearly differing
philosophical assumptions and belief systems. Joppolo, making use of his sense
of moral behavior and precepts of good government, leaves the citizens of Adano
ready to embrace the positive values of democracy. General Marvin has been
bested by the very enlisted men he tyrannizes.
Yet Hersey does not leave
the issues so simple. Paradoxically, the American General Marvin behaves like a
Fascist, while there are former Italian Fascists who are shown to hold
democratic ideals. Similarly, Joppolo must obey his military superior by one
set of operational rules even when moral imperatives drive him to disobedience.
Context
In his various writings
Hersey made a distinction between novels and his journalistic offerings. Novels
he believed to be attempts to illuminate humans caught in events, while
reporting attempts to illuminate the events.
A Bell for Adano is actually a reworking and expansion of a
dispatch that Hersey in his role as war correspondent published in Life magazine (August 23, 1943). Each
person mentioned in the dispatch became a character in the novel; the character
of General Marvin, for example, seems based on the American General George
Patton, whose quick temper became legendary among the troops.
A Bell for Adano exhibits almost none of the modernist techniques and
structural devices evident in novels by Hersey’s renowned predecessors such as
William Faulkner, Ernest Hemingway, and John Dos Passos, or even those of his
more immediate contemporaries such as Saul Bellow, J. D. Salinger, and Joseph
Heller, whose Catch-22 (1961)
became emblematic of the postmodern period in fiction. A Bell for Adano
was purported to be an example of realism in fiction and was accepted by most
of his readers at the time as a realistic portrayal of the American invasion
and of an Italian village and its inhabitants at a particular time in history.
Contemporary reviews of the novel praised Hersey for his true and sympathetic
rendering of believable characters using effective language and a narrative
structure appropriate to the affirmative thrust of the book. Diana Trilling, in
a review published in The Nation, however, asserted that the book could
best be described as consciously contrived simplicity. Nevertheless, A Bell
for Adano remains Hersey’s best-known work. The novel brought Hersey many
awards and prizes and is the major reason for Hersey’s continuing status as an
important writer of fiction.
Perhaps the interest in
clarity and plainspokenness said to be representative of reporters led to
Hersey’s selection of just the right details to cause his novel and the
characters in it to spring to life and to be readily understood by everyone who
read it. This characteristic of the novel may account for its continuing
popularity among readers in their late teens.
Mary
Rohrberger
A Bell
for Adano
Author
John Hersey (1914-1993)
First Published
1944
Classification
Novel
Locale
Adano, Italy
Time of Plot
1943
Type of Plot
Social realism
Major Victor Joppolo (joh-POH- loh), the first military governor of Adano after
the Americans have retaken Italy
in World War II. He is sincerely interested in restoring the dignity of the
people there, and consequently he is willing to suffer what many military men
would consider a lack of respect for their position. He succeeds in replacing
the bell, the town’s most prized possession, which the Fascists had taken.
Sergeant Borth, an outspoken aide to Major Joppolo. He is in complete
sympathy with what the major is trying to do in the town, if not with the
methods he uses.
Captain Purvis, the officer in charge of the military police in Adano.
Adhering rigidly to military regulations, he is careful to report any
infractions of orders, including the major’s countermand of General Marvin’s
order to keep all carts out of Adano.
General Marvin, the overbearing commander-in-chief of the American forces
in Italy.
He cares nothing about the Italian people or their needs and is far too
conscious of his own position and the respect he feels is due him.
Giuseppe (jee-ew-SEH-peh), Major Joppolo’s interpreter, who is
quite proud of his position close to the major.
Tomasino (toh-mah-SEE-noh), a fisherman. He distrusts all authority
and firmly believes in the dignity of the individual.
Gargano (gahr-GAH-noh), an ex- Fascist policeman whom Joppolo
restores to a position of authority.
Lieutenant Trapani (trah-PAH- nee), Captain Purvis’ subordinate. He is not
afraid of the military and is willing to take some liberty with regulations
when the outcome may be helpful.
Colonel Middleton, General Marvin’s aide.
Bell for Adano, A
(Juvenile Literature)
Bell for Adano, A
(Masterplots Classics)
Author Biography
Author
John Hersey (1914-1993)
Type of Work
Novel
Type of Plot
Social realism
Time of Plot
1943
Locale
Adano, Italy
First Published
1944
Author
John Hersey (1914-1993)
Classification
Social realism
First Published
1944
Locale
Adano, Italy
Themes
War, politics and law, social issues, and education
Time of Plot
1943
Recommended Ages
15-18
Author
John Hersey (1914-1993)
First Published
1944
Classification
Novel
Locale
Adano, Italy
Time of Plot
1943
Type of Plot
Social realism